Stephanie H.
7/17/2025
Best pizza in Maryland - my husband (New Yorker) Great service too, everyone is so friendly no matter how busy it is and we love that it is a family business
New York J & P Pizza
$
Closed
(99)
Photos
409 E Ridgeville Blvd
Mount Airy, MD 21771
Benvenuto and welcome to New York J&P Pizza! Owner Frank Illiano learned his chef skills in a bustling bistro kitchen in Italy, and now he’s using his experience to bring delicious, authentic Italian dishes to the community of Mount Airy. While pizza made daily with fresh dough is our namesake, we’re also known for our specialty subs, fresh salads, and your favorite pasta dishes. You can enjoy a dine-in experience with your family, or take advantage of our convenient delivery options. We can cater your special event, too! Any way you enjoy your pizza, we can guarantee happiness by the slice
Reviews
3.599 reviews
Sydney R.
6/2/2024
My go to is definitely the baked ziti here. Perfect portion and sometimes I can even get a second meal out of it for the next day. You do get an option of bread, but I never really eat it all -...
Julie W.
4/17/2025
I specifically ordered gluten- and dairy-free pizza for my kids who have severe allergies. Instead, we were served regular cheese pizza--which led to serious allergic reactions. This is completely...
Bryan W.
4/17/2025
If you have allergies, don't bother coming here or be duped by their dairy-free and gluten-free options. They put whatever they want on your pizza no matter what you order. Our family of eight...
Beth Ann M.
12/2/2022
We've tried both the Mt Airy and the Damascus locations. I've done take out from Damascus a few times and sit down dining at Mt. Airy. I have to say our take out experience has been really hit or...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.