Karis O.
9/2/2025
Neighborhood joint that's serving up freshly made donuts and other baked goods. The Boston creme, is hefty to the point if I try to hold it in one hand with your fingers in the middle, it will...
The Cookie Jar Pastry Shop
$
Closed
(148)
Photos
554 Shore Rd
Cape Elizabeth, ME 04107
Established in the quaint town of Cape Elizabeth, ME, The Cookie Jar Pastry Shop is a beloved destination known for its time-honored traditions. This family-owned bakery exudes charm and warmth, offering a delightful array of freshly prepared donuts, pastries, and custom cakes that have stood the test of time.
Step inside this inviting establishment and treat yourself to not only sweet delights but also savory pleasures like sandwiches and soups. The aroma of freshly baked goods fills the air, welcoming visitors to savor the flavors crafted with care and expertise. At The Cookie Jar Pastry Shop, each bite is a testament to the dedication and passion poured into every creation.
Generated using this place's available information
Reviews
4.5148 reviews
Allie M.
8/15/2025
What a find! Nice old-school style bakery. Reasonable prices. Lots of good stuff to choose from - cookies (duh!); brownies; fruit squares; cinnamon buns; eclairs.....but the star of the show?...
Josh C.
7/25/2025
This is always a favorite stop of ours on the way to Fort Williams. A quaint bakers with a large selection. We love the berry cream turnovers.
Monica L.
8/21/2024
I tried the molasses doughnut today. It was insanely delicious, but also insanely sweet. I wish they would make them without the glaze. Update: I found out today that they do make them without...
Heather R.
9/27/2025
The cookie jar bakery goes out of their way to be helpful and friendly. Several times I went later in the afternoon on busy summer days, and when I found what I like to pick up there was sold out,...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.