Ashley M.
9/21/2025
Came to this place after Louder Than Life around 11pm. It was relatively busy but staff were so friendly. The restaurant was clean and easy to find. The prices were really good for the amount of...
Goodfellas Pizzeria - Baxter Ave
$$
Open
(139)
Photos
642 Baxter Ave Ste 102
Louisville, KY 40204
On Baxter Ave in The Highlands, Goodfellas serves hand-tossed NY-style slices and pies (12", 16", 22"), calzones, and breadsticks with a full bar and craft cocktails. Enjoy the $10 Lunch Special, Tommy “Two Times,” Taste of Naples, and ½-price 12" Mondays. Relax on the patio with TVs and a walk-up bar, book private rentals with a private bar, and explore the Wiseguy Lounge bourbon list. Dine-in, carryout, and delivery. Near Bardstown Road/Restaurant Row and Mid-City Mall. Vegetarian options. Events/Catering: office@goodfellaspizzeria.com
Find related places
Reviews
3.5139 reviews
Nina Z.
10/8/2025
Grabbed a slice here after playing a round of golf in the area. Slices are pretty big and reasonably priced. Tons of seating and a nice chill atmosphere to relax.
Avery E.
8/3/2025
Came back and it was still good. Nice place to grab a slice then head over to the dog bar and watch the puppers I really just love the inside of this place, it's so beautiful and refreshing.
Jamie C.
10/18/2025
This has got to be the worse pizza lol. It used to be really good and now it's just floppy, soggy and greasy. Maybe they're trying to cut back on costs, not sure but it's kinda crap for the price...
Ashleigh B.
10/15/2025
If you post a sign on your door that says open until 12 and it's 9:53 and you have 5 to 7 slices of pizza and 2 breadsticks to sell. And people outside drinking and three guys still tossing dough...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.