Elisa C.
9/7/2025
Always reliable service, quality and atmosphere. Not the best for a really large group but can accommodate 6-8 people in several booths. It is an iconic Iowa City stop!
A & A Pagliai's Pizza
$$
Closed
(208)
Photos
302 E Bloomington St
Iowa City, IA 52245
Open 7 days a week serving our award winning pizza.
A & A Pagliai's Pizza is located in Iowa City, IA, and has been serving the surrounding areas for over 50 years. We offer delicious pizza, ample seating, or fast courteous take-out in just 15 minutes. Come taste for yourself...
Reviews
4.0208 reviews
Bobby C.
8/8/2025
The cheese has gotten less. The bread has gotten more. They burn the crust. The prices are high. It is not the same place from the 90s and early 2000s. They rely on nostalgia and Eastside...
Jen H.
8/30/2025
If you like NY style pizza and beer with zero frills... this is your place. Fast service even at high peak hours and college move in weekend. Loud and classic old school Italian joint with booths...
Robert H.
10/16/2025
Pizza is an experience, and Pagliai's Pizza is a great place to eat pizza. Since the 1970's my family has enjoyed their favorite pizzas made fresh and hot. My patronage has been about 80/20,...
Madonna W.
3/3/2024
Still the BEST PIZZA EVER! I think it's even BETTER! Blah to Coke products, but the pizza is the best! We alternate eating it scalding hot in the restaurant or pick it up for home. Both are so...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.