Josh P.
6/8/2025
Yum! Great staff! Great ice cream! They even made the waffle bowl right in front of me for my Sundae. It's a cute shop and we drove 45 minutes to get here and will be back!
Whitetail Sweet Shop
Closed
(4)
Photos
2020 S Memorial Dr Ste I
New Castle, IN 47362
Whitetail Sweet Shop is a charming confectionery in New Castle, IN, offering a variety of handmade sweets and treats.
With a focus on quality ingredients and traditional recipes, this cozy shop provides a delightful selection of candies and baked goods for locals and visitors alike.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
5.04 reviews
Julie M.
1/7/2024
Are you every lost trying to make a decision because everyone sounds great?! This will induce that feeling. Hard, scooped ice cream, ice cream nachos with delicates little waffle cone wafers as...
Manning M.
8/23/2024
Wow just wow in every sense. Walking in here you already know you're about ready to have a great experience. Amy and Callie were both very kind and although it was very close to closing time they...
Mojo L.
3/8/2025
Small hometown atmosphere ! Wow , these jems are hard to find. Go down and say "hello" it's a wonderful place to take the family and enjoy summer.
See a problem?
