Tomato Pie Pizza Joint

$
Closed
yelp logo

(101)

Photos

100 W Union St
Paragon, IN 46166

Specialties

This is a small town owner operated Pizza Joint. Fresh ingredients, scratch made dough and tomato sauce make this a pizza experince worth the drive. We have the worlds best Breadsticks brushed with Garlic & Herb butter and choice of Marinara or Jalepeno cheese sauces. Our dough is aged for 48 hours for maximum flavor. We cut our Salad fresh daily and make everything to order. Our team at Tomato Pie provide fast and friendly service. Everything at Tomato Pie is served with larger size portions so your going to get your hard earned moneys worth. I'm Kim Raia the owner and I have done a lot of research developing our recipies. I have taught the technique to my staff needed to operate a deck oven properly for that all important perfectly chard crust. This is for sure a skill we all take pride in. This is an Artisan Pizza and Pizza is our passion. I grew up working in my family business at Greiner's Subs-shops in Indianapolis since I was 14. Greiner's offered products above and beyond typical sub-shops, great effort was made to bake gourmet bread, and all ingredients were chosen for quality and taste, without compromise. Greiner's has been operating since 1970. The owner, operator food service concept has dwindled over the years with the onslaught of corporate food marketing, as employees are trained in a static manner, akin to trained seals, as they greet you at the counter. Not so at Tomato Pie, you are coming to this place to discover something that is above the ordinary.

Reviews

yelp logo
4.5101 reviews
Photo of Debbie B.
Debbie B.
9/6/2025

Unbelievable, little pizza place. The pizza was meltin your mouth and your breadsticks as well.

Photo of Colette F.
Colette F.
12/26/2019

Not exactly on the way, but this served as our stopover lunch spot between Cataract Falls and McCormick's Creek State Park. No way we would have found this without Yelp. You order at the counter...

Photo of Martin W.
Martin W.
11/12/2023

What a find. First, the service is impeccable. Carol greeted us at the door and took care of us. I've never had better breadsticks; the salad is enough for two. I expected a ho-hum salad, but this...

Photo of Kara M.
Kara M.
7/7/2019

This is located a little bit of 67. You can't miss it when you drive into Paragon. It's on the right with a neat painted on logo on the building. The building has character and it's nice inside....

Photo of Mica R.
Mica R.
12/4/2022

O. M. G. If youre looking for amazing pizza and breadsticks tucked away in a tiny town, youve found it. People travel from greenwood just to get this pizza!! (Thats us lol) Worth the drive yall!!!...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesIndianaParagonTomato Pie Pizza Joint

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.