John N.
8/26/2025
I was looking for a lightweight electric guitar because I have arthritis in my shoulders George recommended a telecaster that weighed 5 lbs. 10 oz. Almost half the weight my Stratocaster...
The Toy Pit
Closed
(58)
Photos
3827 N College Ave
Indianapolis, IN 46205
The Toy Pit is Indianapolis' largest toy store, offering a wide selection of action figures and toys for all ages.
Located at 9402 Uptown Dr Suite 1700, The Toy Pit is open Tuesday to Sunday, providing a convenient destination for toy enthusiasts in Indianapolis.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.558 reviews
Nicole S.
11/10/2024
I visited The Toy Pit at their new location on College Avenue. You can't miss it -- just look for the amazing mural painted all over the building, which includes pop culture and comic book icons,...
Kimberly W.
12/9/2024
Nicely decorated building, super easy to spot, though if you miss it, look for the Rally's, it's right by that. Inside, there is plenty of space. They could probably add a gaming (of any kind)...
Nichole E.
6/8/2025
Huge store, helpful staff, wall-to-wall nostalgia. My kid was thrilled to find some rare anime merch.
Richard P.
11/11/2024
I will admit that considering the side of town where The Toy Pit is located that I may very well have been expecting a different kind of "toy" pit. That was before I saw their dynamic mural, of...
See a problem?
