Rick G.
12/6/2021
Review is the culmination of a couple of visits Located in historic Metamora, Indiana, Martindale House is a historic building with a wonderful old pub/inn feel. Nicely restored, the decor is a...
The Martindale House
$
Closed
(6)
Photos
19038 S Main St
Metamora, IN 47030
Tavern and Fine Dining in a 19th century atmosphere. Serving British and American cuisine. German cuisine during Oktoberfest Season. Tavern serves cold beer and wine. Building is on the National Historic Registry and was the canal agent's office/store room during the canal era, tavern/inn during the 1850's, and hotel in the 1870's.
Reviews
3.56 reviews
Adrian B.
8/17/2025
There's rustic charm for sure but the tables were sticky and the service was as slow. We felt not existent to start with but our server was a nice guy. They were out of the item I ordered which is...
Lindsey P.
8/27/2022
Nice historic spot for a beer and burger in metamora. Such nice folks for service and good food. The apple bacon jam on the burger was great. Then came the blackberry cobbler. Yes. Stop there for...
Jodie S.
12/7/2019
A little slow on a very busy night but you won't find nicer folks running the place. The pretzels are amazing...get the beer cheese! The Martindale Burger includes pepper jack cheese and bacon...
AmbyMarie M.
11/27/2021
We visited the Martindale house this afternoon and I must say one of the worst experiences I have had. The waitress had zero personality and no knowledge of the menu. We had nine people in our...
See a problem?
