Gary W.
1/18/2023
This small mom and pop's on the side of hill is a great hidden gem. We stopped in after passing the restaurant several times. We were not disappointed with the food or the service. We were a...
The Hilltop Restaurant
Closed
(26)
Photos
300 Wayne St
Middlebury, IN 46540
Nestled in the charming town of Middlebury, IN, The Hilltop Restaurant stands out as a beacon of American culinary tradition. From the moment one steps inside, the warm ambiance and inviting aromas set the stage for a memorable dining experience. The restaurant's menu is a delightful fusion of classic comfort food and innovative twists, catering to a diverse range of palates.
Whether craving a hearty burger, a fresh salad, or a decadent dessert, The Hilltop Restaurant delivers on all fronts. With friendly service and a cozy atmosphere, patrons can unwind and savor each bite in the company of friends and family. This American gem in Middlebury is not just a place to eat—it's a destination for those seeking a taste of home with a dash of culinary creativity.
Generated using this place's available information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.026 reviews
Cynthia M.
6/20/2025
Two breakfasts were $38 with 19% tip. Pricey. Service was good and order was brought fairly quick. Fresh sausage was good but could have had more flavor/spices. Bacon, eggs (scrambled and over...
Jeanette S.
8/2/2025
A warning, when you order a piece of blueberry pie, be aware they have a "fresh" blueberry pie, which consist of fresh (unbaked) blueberries, in blue food color tinted, tasteless gelatin. The...
Ali S.
6/13/2024
Never made it to the previous location before the fire... been waiting for years to finally go to this new (to me) location. The experience overall was disappointing. Cute and inviting exterior....
J. S.
12/30/2024
I'll start by saying I think the strength of the place is their all day breakfast. That said, this was just ok from a dinner point of view. I had so-so coleslaw with slightly too much mayo for me....
See a problem?
