Crystal P.
9/20/2025
Of course coming to this area we had to get some cookies from here. The woman was nice enough to give my son a sample cookie who then gave her a thumbs up lol. Brody approved! Cute little bakery...
Rookies Cookies
$
Closed
(9)
Photos
310 Pearl St
New Albany, IN 47150
Rookies Cookies is a family owned and operated bakery that has been serving the New Albany, IN area for 82 years. Contact us today for more information!
Also at this address
Reviews
4.59 reviews
Victoria T.
8/14/2014
You would, no doubt, be shocked to find that I am subject to some of the same flaws and faults as mere mortals. I'm particularly vulnerable to the...
Andy S.
10/11/2010
Rookies Cookies is located on Pearl st. in downtown New Albany right where Federal Hill used to be. Easy enough to find but you'll be lucky if you can catch them open. I've gone to their store...
Shana K.
2/5/2014
Rookies Cookies is a gem that is tucked away in downtown New Albany. If not for Yelp I might have completely missed out of this amazing find. As the name implies, Rookies Cookies, specializes...
Chris A.
2/28/2022
New Albany legendary bakery. Take the cookies to out of town friends & relatives and you'll be a big hit
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.