Polly's Freeze

$
Open
yelp logo

(87)

Photos

5242 State Road 62
Georgetown, IN 47122
Since 1952 an iconic local walk up order window restaurant and ice cream shop. Step back into 1952 where shakes, burgers, and fries are still served underneath the bright neon parrot.

Reviews

yelp logo
4.587 reviews
Photo of Trisha B.
Trisha B.
11/17/2025

I have been visiting this quaint place for decades. It is generally crowded but service is typically fast. I like that they added more parking. I like the frozen banana. I would like to see sugar...

Photo of Katy E.
Katy E.
5/7/2025

My hubby and I decided to check out Polly's freeze, an ice cream joint we had heard about many times from the locals. We headed over. It was busy and they have fun items like pickle popsicle and...

Photo of Emily H.
Emily H.
6/29/2023

Polly's Freeze is a regional treat, and I'm glad I finally had the opportunity to visit. My family and I stopped after our trip to Bryant's Blueberries. I got an Oreo flurry. My husband got a...

Photo of Gail P.
Gail P.
6/20/2025

Absolutely delish. I went with the twist soft serve topped with crunch coat which is a mixture of broken up nuts and multicolored sprinkles. The soft serve is so creamy and flavorful that you'll...

Photo of Jeffrey D.
Jeffrey D.
11/10/2024

About 3 months ago, we relocated to the southeastern area of Indiana from southcentral Kentucky. The first several days of unpacking all suggested "You must try Polly's Freeze! It's a landmark...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesIndianaGeorgetownPolly's Freeze

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.