We were greeted right away and seated quickly. The waitress was friendly, kept our drinks full, and the food was hot, tasty, and well-portioned. Nice, inviting atmosphere great place to relax with...
Polito's Pizzeria Restaurant
$$
Closed
(180)
Photos
401 N Hickory Rd
South Bend, IN 46615
Discover the delicious offerings we have every day of the week.
Reviews
Amanda T.
10/21/2025
B G.
10/17/2025
I had the Stromboli pepperoni, onion cheese. Lots of crust that had no taste. If it wasn't for the side of sauce to give it some taste. Would have been better if they used pizza crust with pizza...
Karen M.
7/6/2024
Always great pizza. It's our go-to for close to NY style pizza, although we did recently order the beautiful tricolor Sicilian pizza pictured below .
Mike R.
11/13/2024
When we first found Polito's in 1995 we thought wow real New York style pizza what a treat here in South Bend! Went there a lot in the old days with the kids, not as much in the past few years....
victoria e.
3/8/2025
Best New York pizza away from home. It's hard to find a good pizza place in the Midwest when you're from the northeast.
Owner verified
See a problem?







