Susan G.
10/18/2025
Stopped for a quick bite and we were not disappointed! Ordered two small pizzas because we couldn't decide. Sausage and mushroom and a delectable fig jam, goat cheese, arugula, olive oil,...
Pizza Uncommon
$
Closed
(86)
Photos
1522 Win Hentschel Blvd
West Lafayette, IN 47906
Pizza Uncommon is a West Lafayette-based restaurant that specializes in creative New York style pizza, homemade gelato, and uniquely crafted drinks.
With a focus on quality and innovation, Pizza Uncommon offers a menu that combines traditional flavors with unexpected twists, providing a truly uncommon dining experience.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.586 reviews
Shafina I.
10/7/2025
Went to try some unique pizzas and ice cream. This place is creative with both their pizza toppings and ice cream flavors. Tried the crab rangoon (my fave), blackberry goat cheese, Nashville hot...
Lydia B.
5/17/2025
Loved the pizza! There was a really good crust on it, but just beware the flop is heeeavy. Youll need to support it the whole way down. My brother (congrat grad!) got pepperoni and it looked...
Sruthi K.
2/17/2024
Easily one of the best pizzas I've tried. The sauce for the Shiitake Mushroom Truffle was rich and creamy. They were very generous with the mushrooms. The dough for the pizza and breadsticks was...
Beth B.
5/13/2025
We had an everything pizza minus green peppers on a Saturday afternoon before Mother's Day. You place your order at the counter, then they bring the pizza to your table. The drinks are by the can...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.