Penn Station East Coast Subs

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(41)

Photos

9785 E 116th St
Fishers, IN 46037
Our menu features an array of mouth watering Grilled Penn Station submarine sandwiches, fresh-cut fries and hand-squeezed lemonade. All sandwiches are prepared fresh in full view of the customer using delicious hearth-baked bread, USDA Choice Steak and the finest meats, cheeses and vegetables. The potatoes are hand selected, fresh-cut and flash-fried in cholesterol-free peanut oil. The lemonade is made from scratch every day using hand-squeezed lemons.

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
3.041 reviews
Chandler W.
9/30/2025

Never have any problems with this place. The food is always spot on. The service is always great

Photo of Sheree W.
Sheree W.
8/17/2024

Came here because I had a coupon 2 small subs, 2 small fries and 2 small drinks for 22 dollars. Had to wait a few minutes to for someone to take my order, even though nobody was in front of us,...

Zach T.
2/11/2025

The food was great. service was fast and friendly, Nick was an amazing server. His amazing attitude made my day

Photo of Jess M.
Jess M.
11/30/2023

Decent sandwiches and delicious fries. Not sure I'd call this a favorite, but it definitely hit the spot. Make sure to load up on the condiments if you get the multigrain - mine was pretty dry.

Mc M.
3/4/2025

Ordered a turkey and swiss sub made "East Coast style" as per their menu suggested. The woman asked if I wanted my sandwich hot or cold I told her cold. It took a long time to prepare and when I...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesIndianaFishersPenn Station East Coast Subs