Over the Top Bakery Cafe

$
Closed
yelp logo

(17)

Photos

112 N Main St
North Liberty, IN 46554
Where you can get your handmade cookies, cakes, donuts, and more. Enjoy are fresh ground coffee and custom tea bar.

Reviews

yelp logo
5.017 reviews
Photo of Jeff K.
Jeff K.
7/13/2025

We've only had the Philly cheesesteak sandwich, but OMG! Possibly the best ever, and my wife is from Philly. The beef is perfectly spiced, the roll made fresh, and the peppers and onions are...

Photo of G S.
G S.
9/7/2022

Great business, call ahead big orders. Delicious donut. Convenient to the location and kind helpful staff

Photo of Clinton C.
Clinton C.
5/26/2022

Went in here looking for the sugar cookie of my childhood! Guess what.. they had them! The thin and Ooey gooey crystalized sugar sprinkled cookie was there! Delicious !!

Jill V.
4/28/2024

They have the best donuts! Truly a treasure in a small town! It should be a destination spot for donut dreamers. We have also had them make a birthday cake for our daughter and she was beyond...

Photo of L S.
L S.
7/2/2020

Perfect cupcakes, not too big, icing was chilled and not overwhelming and not too sweet..... PERFECT! Hummingbird cupcake was my favorite. They do breakfast. they do donuts, they do muffins,...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesIndianaNorth LibertyOver the Top Bakery Cafe

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.