Viki R.
6/6/2025
The best custard in town! Not always the fastest service but worth waiting on. Of course it's still early in the season. Got to give the new employees time to learn the ropes.
Original Frozen Custard
$
Closed
(59)
Photos
2319 Wallace Ave
Lafayette, IN 47904
Original Frozen Custard serves the Lafayette, Indiana community with delicious frozen custard. Our secret recipe has been passed down from generation to generation since 1932. Our homemade frozen custard has been a staple in the community for years, bringing people to our frozen custard shop for the best frozen treats. We serve various flavors of frozen custard, fresh fruit drink, sandwiches, old fashioned sodas, ice cream sundaes, shakes, malts and other desserts. Visit our frozen custard shop located across from the Columbian Park Zoo and taste why our frozen custard is the best in town.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.059 reviews
Jessica M.
8/28/2024
Super old school and straight forward. Our family of four were returning from our Indianapolis-Cincinnati road trip and made a pit stop here for a quick snack before continuing to Chicago. It was...
Megan F.
7/15/2025
We wanted a cool treat after spending the morning outside. We were the 3rd car in the drive-thru which I guess meant 23 minutes to get custard. Out of the 4 items we got 2 were so gross that we...
Keith R.
4/30/2024
WOW FACTOR? Yes, the frozen custard was particular delicious this visit. HAVE AGAIN: Chocolate/vanilla twist was wonderful, better than I remember.
Abigail W.
5/17/2023
My daughter as I stopped here to get a treat. I wanted a regular size butterfinger, but even though the flavor was written in their white board, they didn't have it, so I went with strawberry. My...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.