Jerry E.
9/27/2025
The waitresses are always nice and friendly. The service is always fast and the pizza is good
Old Time Pizza
$
Open
(17)
Photos
19152 Market St
New Paris, IN 46553
Old Time Pizza is a hometown restaurant specializing in bountiful pizza, juicy broasted chicken and pork chops, and much more!
Reviews
3.517 reviewsBob Z.
2/23/2024
Did carry out order of their Broasted Chicken. It's wonderful! Very moist, even the white meat. Definitely will put this on my list for carry out. Service was good, was ready when I got there....
Howard R.
2/3/2023
Our favorite go to for a small town pizza and they pork chops there is great too , giving this place a shot will be worth your time and money
Eddie V.
10/2/2022
My wife grew up in Benton, we moved back here after her being gone for 30 years and she immediately wanted a pizza from here. I got it for her and she still loved it. We get it whenever we have...
Arabella D.
5/27/2023
It's alright. Food is usually a little burnt. The spaghetti has mushrooms in it and I think that's gross.
See a problem?
