Ericka D.
1/27/2020
The pie is pricey, but it is definitely the best version of a sugar cream pie I have ever had! Sugar cream pie is a must try if you're visiting Indiana for the first time, and My Sugar Pie is the...
My Sugar Pie
Permanently closed
(12)
Photos
1251 US-31 N Unit P170A
Greenwood, IN 46142
My Sugar Pie, located in Greenwood, IN, specializes in gourmet homemade pies that delight customers with their unique offerings. Known for their signature rhubarb and strawberry pie, this charming establishment invites patrons to indulge in a slice of tradition and taste.
In addition to their delicious pies, My Sugar Pie provides an easy online ordering system and e-gift cards for convenience. The shop often experiences high demand, particularly around holidays, so customers are encouraged to plan their orders in advance.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.512 reviews
Sara B.
4/8/2019
I was really in the mood for pie one day and drove all the way to Greenwood to try out My Sugar Pie! First, the shop is super cute! I love the way it's set up and that it's right next to a mall...
Ken N.
2/6/2019
Even though I live in Mooresville, I was the Duke of the Zionsville home location of this business. So, when I heard that a second location was opening on the south side inside the Greenwood Park...
Deb R.
11/28/2019
We purchased two pies. A sugar cream pie and an apple pie. Rated on a 10 scale : Sugar cream pie - 6 - It was a bit too heavy, pasty and super rich/sugary for me. The crust was commendable...
Jason W.
2/26/2019
Friendly people and delicious pies! One of the Indy area's best pie shops is now on the south side. My wife has declared their Key Lime as "better than the one I just had in Florida." Expect to...
See a problem?
