John K.
8/2/2025
Fantastic Chicken Marsalis. Service was definitely five star. Such a charming house and the patio/garden makes you think you are in Italy. Over all a five star restaurant with a home type feeling.
Mama Carolla's
$$
Closed
(1,199)
Photos
1031 E 54th St
Indianapolis, IN 46220
Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant is a charming dining establishment in Indianapolis, IN that specializes in serving traditional Italian cuisine.
With a cozy atmosphere and a menu featuring classic dishes, Mama Carolla's is a popular choice for those seeking a taste of Italy in the heart of the Midwest.
Generated from their business information
Find related places
Reviews
4.51,199 reviewsJenn L.
8/15/2025
Amazing food and the the service was extraordinary! The artichokes were phenomenal. Both the pastas we had were incredible as well! Thank you for a wonderful experience!
Sydney T.
7/18/2025
Mama Carolla's is one of our absolute favorite Italian restaurants in Indianapolis! The atmosphere is warm, classic, and cozy--perfect for a special night out. We kicked things off with an Italian...
Kathleen S.
8/25/2025
Mama Carolla's has such a charming, old-world atmosphere. It's a very cozy spot that is perfect for date night or family dinner. We started with the stuffed mushrooms, which I thought was okay....
Christie L.
8/7/2025
The place is adorable. Food is amazing. People are wonderful. Went for a birthday dinner for a friend and as always, loved the atmosphere. This place is quaint and small. Tried four appetizers,...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.