Megan V.
8/16/2025
This place! The retro atmosphere made me instantly think of the old Shakey's! The food was great, the server was attentive and friendly, and again, the atmosphere just brought me back in time! I...
Lenny's Coal Fired Pizza
Open
(38)
Photos
3800 Calumet Ave
Valparaiso, IN 46383
Lenny's Coal Fired Pizza, brought to you by Costas Restaurant Group, is Valparaiso's newest and most unique pizza restaurant, offering traditional coal-fired pizza inspired by iconic pizza restaurants in New Haven, Connecticut. With a newly renovated restaurant that brings the 70s back to life, Lenny's also features tasty wings, pasta, and salads, making it a favorite among locals.
Experience the joyride for your senses at Lenny's, where you can indulge in their signature coal-fired pizzas, including the popular Buffalo Chicken Pizza of the Month, as well as other mouthwatering options like the New Haven Tomato Pie and the Pesto Chicken Pie. With a focus on quality ingredients and a taste of the East Coast, Lenny's is a must-visit for pizza lovers in Valpo.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.538 reviews
Nicole S.
7/14/2025
Nice place with a bar, indoor window seating, booths and tables, or you can sit out on the patio. The service was friendly and attentive. We got a thin crust pepperoni pizza and a BYO calzone. The...
Matt G.
10/13/2024
Not sure what the lower reviews are all about here, we had a great experience. Now when it comes to pizza being called, "New Haven", it's close -- but it's not New Haven. The plain pizza had a...
Kyle C.
1/9/2025
Been a little bit since our last time at Lenny's, and it's just as good if not better than our first time there. Their weekday happy hour deals are epic too. You gotta go, specifically start the...
Wendy B.
9/22/2025
Ordered an all meat pizza and they put 4 tiny pepperoni's on most slices and one had 3. How is that all meat?
See a problem?
