Scott V.
8/31/2025
I used to enjoy Jimmy John's. They really were freaky fast. They had freebies including Dijon mustard. In the last couple of years, I've noticed a decline in quality of the sandwiches. They...
Jimmy John's
$
Closed
(21)
Photos
4741 S Scatterfield Rd
Anderson, IN 46013
We slice our all-natural meats and fresh veggies in-house every day. Our fresh-baked bread is made right here where you can see it, and our house-made tuna salad is fresh every day. The flavor of a ripe tomato, crisp shredded lettuce, combined with fresh-baked bread, fresh-sliced meat and real Hellmann's mayo - that's when the magic happens. Made with love every single day since 1983. That's Jimmy Fresh!
Reviews
2.021 reviews
Matt H.
10/20/2024
Clearly this location is not looking to resolve the issue of me being ripped off. Keep this up and see how long you stay in business! From now on, I suggest everyone skip this day care/sub shop...
N K.
12/15/2024
Bread wreaks and tastes of cigarette smoke (I am not a cigarette smoker). Sandwich was prepared poorly. Usually love jimmy johns but this crew isn't doing it right.
Jenny E.
7/8/2024
Stopped 10 min before closing and staff refused to take the order of our 3 young boys who just finished soccer camp, but took the young girl's order who walked in just before us. Went to subway...
Nathan S.
6/6/2024
2pm and they are out of bread. Took a while to serve us our food (not freaky fast). Bathroom was a mess. Didn't seem like any other Jimmy John's I've been to.
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.