Greg S.
9/6/2025
Great pizza, super friendly staff that genuinely seemed to enjoy their jobs and each other.
Greek Tony's Pizza & Sub Shop
$
Closed
(189)
Photos
1732 E 116th St
Carmel, IN 46032
Greek Tony's Pizza Sub Shop has been a beloved pizza destination in Carmel, Indiana, for nearly 40 years, renowned for its great taste and good times. The establishment prides itself on making fresh dough for its pizzas and breadsticks every morning, attracting customers who travel long distances for their famous garlic butter-covered breadsticks.
With a focus on using only the freshest ingredients, Greek Tony's offers made-to-order slices and a buffet-style dining experience that includes all-you-can-eat salad, breadsticks, and pizza. The venue also features a spacious party room, perfect for various celebrations, and provides catering options to accommodate larger gatherings.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.0189 reviews
Katherine A.
11/3/2024
I love this old school, family-run pizza shop close to downtown Carmel. And the hype about the breadsticks is real - the sticks are hot, chewy and addictive! The restaurant is not trendy or...
Lee S.
7/10/2025
It's a hole-in-the-wall kinda place - and a very good one. Fast, friendly service. The buttery garlic breadsticks are the absolute best. We usually share the veggie sub and dine at one of the...
Madi D.
11/7/2025
Placed my order online and waited until the time it said to pick up and then continued to wait another hour at the restaurant because they didn't put my order to the kitchen until after I sat...
Laura D.
8/30/2025
The best sub sandwich's !!! The steak sub supreme is my favorite!!! I usually do carry out but they excellent and friendly always!!! It's the best last Joint in Carmel
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.