Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave

$
Closed
tripadvisor logo

(34)

Call
Website

Photos

545 Massachusetts Ave
Indianapolis, IN 46204
+1 (317) 602-3401
https://www.goodfellaspizzeria.com
On Massachusetts Avenue, Goodfellas serves hand-tossed NY-style slices and pies (12", 16", 22") with stone-baked crusts, plus calzones and breadsticks and a full bar. Signatures include the $10 Lunch Special, Tommy “Two Times,” Taste of Naples, and ½-price 12" Mondays. Seasonal outdoor seating, private rentals with a private bar, and the Wiseguy Lounge bourbon list. Dine-in and carryout. Near the Mass Ave Cultural Arts District, Gainbridge Fieldhouse, Old National Centre, and The Athenaeum. Vegetarian options. Events/Catering: office@goodfellaspizzeria.com

Also at this address

Find related places

Restaurants

Reviews

tripadvisor logo
4.034 reviews
Photo of LaNelle L
Horrible customer Service
3/24/2024

I would like to speak with a manager when I asked for a manager "Bria" told me there wasn't one then...

Read more on Tripadvisor
Photo of BrianD317
Good lunch special for under $10.00
3/28/2023

I like to come here sometimes for the lunch special. One slice of pizza, a very large breadstick wi...

Read more on Tripadvisor
Photo of Hoosier_Travel_Nut
Meh, ok. Nothing memorable
9/29/2022

A friend and I went here after an IUPUI soccer match. It wasn't busy. We each selected a slice of pe...

Read more on Tripadvisor
Owner verified
See a problem?

You might also like

Bazbeaux Pizza
Eating places, Italian restaurant, Pizzeria, independent

Bazbeaux Pizza

781
•
$$
"I've been going to Bazbeaux for over 20 years, and it's still my go-to spot for pizza. The service is always friendly, the atmosphere is warm and welcoming, and most importantly, the food is..."
photo of Theresa G.
Abbiocco Pizzeria
Eating places, Italian restaurant

Abbiocco Pizzeria

53
•
$$
"Can you appreciate a crispy, thin-crust, classic pepperoni pie? If you answered yes, you should definitely give this place a try. I've eaten here several times, and nothing beats ordering this..."
photo of Kandice T.
Giorgio's Pizza
Eating places, Italian restaurant

Giorgio's Pizza

271
•
$
"Came in for lunch and ordered two slices, The inside looks a little dated, but with nice pictures. The pizza itself was pretty good for Indianapolis, New York style pizza spot. I would definitely..."
photo of Jared C.
United States›Indiana›Indianapolis›Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Yext