Amanda S.
1/2/2019
4 stars because we've only been here once- but we loved it! The restaurant itself was clean, the one member of staff we met was friendly. We avoided the buffet that looked like it had been...
East of Chicago Pizza Company
$
Closed
(40)
Photos
350 S Van Buren St Ste C
Shipshewana, IN 46565
East of Chicago Pizza Company in Shipshewana, IN, offers a diverse menu featuring signature pizzas and the option to build your own. Their selection also includes fresh oven-baked subs, a variety of wings, and delicious desserts.
Known for their specialty items like the American BLT and the Chicken Bacon Ranch Deluxe, East of Chicago Pizza Company caters to a range of tastes. The restaurant aims to provide a satisfying dining experience for both pizza lovers and those seeking hearty subs and sides.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.540 reviews
Greg C.
6/21/2025
Placed online order for pickup. American sub & boneless wings. After 1 hr of waiting I could not stand around any longer. I asked them to credit my order as I walked out the door. We'll...
Tera R.
6/2/2025
Great price for salad, soup, Italian sandwiches, pizza buffet. Salad bar is pretty small, but had items I like, only iceberg lettuce however. Pizzas were good, not too much sauce, which I like. I...
Jeannette B.
3/14/2025
Pizza was really good but TURN THE DAMN MUSIC DOWN!!!! Came to visit and couldn't hear a word across the table.
Beverly G.
6/8/2024
Wow!!! I'm not normally a deep dish pizza person but decided to try it after seeing reviews. This is one of the best pizzas I've eaten!!! Will definitely come here the next time we are in...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.