Caitlin S.
11/16/2025
I was attending a conference at the AMP and was craving pizza on the second day. Butler's was the perfect fix, and much tastier than a lot of the other fast DIY pizza places I've had in the past....
Butler's Pizza
Closed
(16)
Photos
1220 Waterway Blvd
Indianapolis, IN 46202
Butler's Pizza, founded in 1990 as a family-run business, has been a staple on the west side of Indianapolis, honoring its legacy by serving delicious pizzas made with love and care. The company has grown over the years and now operates three branches, offering a wide range of pizzas, breadsticks, and sandwiches crafted from carefully selected, high-quality ingredients.
With a team of skilled cooks, including Cantrell, Amanda, Paula, and Tonya, who each bring over 20 years of experience to the kitchen, Butler's Pizza is dedicated to using only the freshest ingredients. Their passion for food is evident in every dish, and they are always eager to share their culinary expertise with customers.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.516 reviews
Amber B.
8/8/2025
We visited the AMP and decided to try Butlers Pizza! It was really easy to order. The pizza came out timely and was hot and had fresh ingredients! I really enjoyed the bbq sauce instead of the...
Sydney J.
11/13/2025
Service was really rude. Create your own pizzas not slices, they are rectangle pieces, for the price it's not worth it at all.
Julie S.
5/16/2025
The Best locally owned pizza place around Do yourself a huge favor Come to this spot
Faren J.
8/29/2024
It's hard to recommend what to get here because everything is I usually get the lunch special...and so often that they know my name as well as my order by heart. I always forget to take a picture...
See a problem?
