Butler's Pantry

It is our mission to bring you only the freshest ingredients. We’ve chosen traditionally aged balsamic vinegars from Modena, Italy and the freshest extra virgin olive oils imported from around the world. We strongly believe that extra virgin olive oil is like freshly squeezed fruit juice. Our olive oils are cold pressed, first pressed and are high in polyphenols, which make them healthier and more flavorful. The anti-inflammatory properties of our olive oils are a reason to use them everyday. Zionsville Olive Oil carries over 36 of the highest quality small-batch EVOOs, specialty oils and vinegars from around the world. Taste before you buy, then watch as your selections are freshly poured, corked and sealed.