Hayley T.
9/29/2025
The food was DELICIOUS! Some of the best pizza! Top pizza -- their monthly special called The Velvet Sheep Pesto, provolone, pepperoni, peppers, ricotta, and honey. Bottom pizza -- Pecora...
Black Sheep Pizza
$$
Open
(27)
Photos
345 4th St
Columbus, IN 47201
Black Sheep Pizza in Columbus, IN, brings a fresh take on the traditional pizza experience. Embracing the motto "Flock to what's good," the eatery offers a diverse menu featuring innovative pizzas and a selection of drinks to complement every meal.
Located at 345 4th Street, Black Sheep Pizza invites patrons to enjoy a unique dining experience in a vibrant setting. With opening hours extending from Monday to Sunday, customers can savor their favorite pizzas at their convenience, whether for a casual lunch or dinner outing.
Generated from the website content
Reviews
4.527 reviews
Natalie V.
10/24/2025
The pizza at Black Sheep is phenomenal. Cooked perfectly. We had the Etna and the special pizza. Both were fantastic. In the past we've had their cocktails and they're also great. For the...
Audrey G.
5/2/2025
The pizzas and salads at this place were pretty good! I'm not a fru-fru pizza person- I want an old fashioned NYC slice that I can fold and chomp into. However, Black sheep was chosen by the...
Ellen F.
4/29/2025
My partner and I came by on a Sunday afternoon, to find this was one of the only restaurants open on a Sunday in the area. The ambiance is lovely inside, making a luxury feel with still a very...
Deb G.
4/19/2025
Black Sheep was a great lunch experience. My family and I loved the decor - so many cool black sheep to look at, from the life size ones at the entrance to the lit up wall displays to the...
See a problem?