Bagel Fair

$
Closed
yelp logo

(235)

Call
Website

Photos

1300 E 86th St
Indianapolis, IN 46240
+1 (317) 846-0950
http://bagelfair.com

Bagel Fair Incorporated is a 2nd generation family-owned business located in Nora Plaza Shopping Center in Indianapolis, IN. Established in 1975, they are known for their fresh, authentic New York bagels made from a family recipe over 100 years old.

With a wide variety of bagel flavors and cream cheese spreads, Bagel Fair offers a delicious selection of bagel sandwiches and beverages. Their bialys, a unique baked alternative to boiled bagels, are a popular choice among customers. Experience Indy's only real New York bagels at Bagel Fair.

Generated from the website

Also at this address

Find related places

Restaurants

Reviews

yelp logo
4.5235 reviews
Photo of Charlene S.
Charlene S.
9/4/2025

I used to live in Indy. In 1975 I would drive there very early on Sundays to get Bialys. I loved them! Now I'm in Seattle home of dreadful bagels and frozen bialys. I miss the funny sign on the...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Candace T.
Candace T.
10/7/2025

The servers are fine. Attentive and helpful. The place looks very clean. The bagels are no better than those you can buy at a supermarket. Maybe worse than some. I purchased 6 sesame bagels, a...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Lizz M.
Lizz M.
9/23/2025

The bagels and cream cheese from here are great! Walked in and the employees were not attentive, despite no other customers being in. I just got 6 different bagels to try and take to the office. I...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Denise C.
Denise C.
12/6/2024

Not too many fresh bagel shops in Indiana. I had always wanted to come try this place. It's about 30 plus minutes north of my home. They also close early, 2pm. I got a dozen bagels everything,...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Elizabeth S.
Elizabeth S.
5/12/2025

Went Mother's Day morning. Long line but moved fast! Great prices. The plain bagels were so fresh there were still warm. Good selection. Will definitely go again.

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Titus Bakery
Eating places, Pastries, Doughnuts

Titus Bakery

191
•
$
"The chocolate Bismarck's are my favorite but a close second is the apple fritter that's as big as my head!"
photo of Katelyn W.
Eating places, Services, nec, nec, Business services, nec, nec

Harlan Bakeries

$
Harlan Bakeries LLC, is a family owned business that produces a wide range of bakery products and dry bakery mixes. Our foundation was with premium quality Kosher bagels and bagel related products, but our growth has made our product line even wider each year. The original company was founded in November of 1990 by brothers Hugh & Doug Harlan. The company has continued to grow each year and we have acquired some other brands and companies along the way as well as expanded our current facilities. In 2000 Kyger Bakery Products Inc. was purchased and we expanded into production of quality pies. 2002 Harlan purchased A.C.E. Baking Company, Inc. of Denver CO and expanded our reach in bagel products. In 2005 Harlan purchased various facilities of Meyers Bakeries and launched Southern Bakeries, LLC. This division of Harlan Bakeries provides some great bread products and English muffins to expand the scope of our product offerings.
Mary Lou Donuts
Eating places, Doughnuts

Mary Lou Donuts

130
•
$
"I'm writing this with the donut sweats. It's like the meat sweats but better. So I live in Westfield but I work in Lafayette currently. One of my co workers has the hookup for this place and I..."
photo of Amy R.
United States›Indiana›Indianapolis›Bagel Fair

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.