Jessica C.
8/1/2025
Regularly order from here....always super polite over the phone and food is always on point....hidden secret but definitely try the biscuits and apple butter....thank me later!!
Aunt Polly's Pizza
$
Closed
(70)
Photos
5339 English Ave
Indianapolis, IN 46219
This is "The Original" Aunt Polly's Pizza - Established 1970!
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.070 reviews
Christia W.
9/12/2025
Ordered pizza and her delivery driver never showed up. Manager stated that she didn't care and would not refund me my money. Still waiting .
latansy h.
8/20/2025
This was the worst Pizza I have ever seen or tasted when they were on Michigan Street back in the early 2000 they were the bomb I went to the one on East Street last night I had asked for ground...
Joe J.
2/6/2025
Can't beat it. They let us know ahead of time, it would be longer than usual for delivery. They made it within the quoted time. Pizza and bread sticks were fresh and the onion rings still...
William W.
4/7/2025
Pizza is always terrific. Delivery was quick and the driver was nice and friendly. We love Aunt Polly's!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.