Nikki P.
7/5/2025
Arrenello's is mine and my partners go to! We order on a weekly basis, BEST pizza hands down in Northwest Indiana!
Arrenello's Pizza
$$
Closed
(75)
Photos
2556 45th St
Highland, IN 46322
Family owned and operated, your family has been gathering around the table to enjoy our award winning stuffed pizza since 1972. We appreciate & thank you for loving our stuffed for almost 50 years!! That's-some-sweet-sauce!!
Also at this address
Reviews
3.075 reviews
Michelle M.
3/28/2024
I've ordered from this spot for about two decades. LOVE this spot. The pizza is exceptional. I mean. Really good. However tonight, I had a less than great experience with service. I called at...
Tim U.
1/19/2025
I've been eating Arrenello's for 33 years (started in Glenwood until I moved to Highland). I claim to be a foodie and am very willing to try all pizza style. Nothing compares. Arrenello's is,...
Pam H.
2/1/2025
We moved from Hammond 14 years ago. When we visit we bring a pizza back to our daughter's near St. Louis. The food in NW Indiana is surely missed!!!
Mike T.
2/20/2025
Not a fan at all the sauce is ridiculously sweet. Like I can handle Aurelio's sweet but this pizza is like cheesecake sweet I'll pass next time!
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.