Amanda's Exchange

$$
Open
yelp logo

(93)

Call
Website

Photos

715 E Carmel Dr
Carmel, IN 46032
+1 (317) 573-4400
http://www.amandasexchange.shop

Amanda's Exchange, located in Carmel, IN, offers a curated selection of fashionable clothing, accessories, and home décor for discerning shoppers. With a commitment to quality and community support, the locally owned consignment store has been a trusted destination since 2002.

Specializing in both women's and children's apparel, Amanda's Exchange caters to a diverse array of styles, including athletic wear, boutique pieces, vintage finds, and formal attire. The store also provides a seamless consignment experience, promoting sustainability and allowing customers to turn their gently used items into cash.

Generated from the website

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
3.593 reviews
Cordin K.
9/10/2025

Higher pricing, but also quality clothing. Very well organized by brand or clothing type. Mostly women's clothes, some children's/men's and some home decor/furniture.

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Tyanna M.
Tyanna M.
9/6/2024

I liked this shop. I found plenty of fun clothes to check out. There were home decor items and furniture as well. It was a good sized store and I found plenty of items I liked. The prices were on...

Read more on Yelp
Susi W.
10/21/2025

I have consigned with Amanda's several times. my clothing and shoes are very high quality. I took a cart of clothing there but they took nothing, saying it smelled "musty". There were brand...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Mia T.
Mia T.
5/16/2024

After my last review, the owner reached out to me to correct the situation. Originally I wanted to give Amanda's Exchange 5 stars until the shoe situation happened. Given the customer service,...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Jerri S.
Jerri S.
5/22/2024

I've been one of Amanda's loyal customers since her beginnings next to Puccinis. Look everything over because I did need to alter this dress a little myself and it fit!!!

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Broad Ripple Vintage
Women's specialty clothing stores, Custom and orthopedic shoes, Clothing and shoes, secondhand

Broad Ripple Vintage

83
•
$$
"YES. I. LOVE. THIS. STORE. This was the very first thrift store I found when I moved to Indianapolis 8 years ago, and I couldn't have been happier with a thrift store. Tried and true, this place..."
photo of Haley C.
Women's specialty clothing stores, Office furniture and store fixtures, secondhand

Plato’s Closet

1
"I think this is the BEST Plato's Closet around central Indiana. They have the best selection of trendy clothing. Without a doubt you can find Free People, Aerie, Zara - I recently found a like new..."
photo of Isabelle M.
Women's specialty clothing stores

Retulled Consignment Boutique

Retulled Consignment Boutique in Indianapolis, IN offers a wide selection of wedding attire and accessories for brides-to-be. From wedding dresses to bridal jewelry, they provide options for all sizes and styles. With a focus on unique and personalized wedding ideas, Retulled Consignment Boutique aims to help couples plan their special day with ease. Their privacy policy ensures that customers' personal information is kept confidential. Generated from the website
United States›Indiana›Carmel›Amanda's Exchange

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.