Shawn M.
6/3/2025
The tables are so gross and vey sticky. Ice cream was good tho. Or maybe a station where they have clean towels for customers to do it themselves.
Alexander's on the Square- Cicero
$
Closed
(39)
Photos
369 W Jackson St
Cicero, IN 46034
Alexander's on the Square, located in downtown Noblesville, specializes in 36 flavors of hand-dipped ice cream alongside a diverse menu featuring fresh salads, sandwiches, and wraps. In addition to its extensive ice cream selection, the establishment is known for its famous jumbo breaded tenderloin and delicious homemade chili.
Alexander's on the Water, situated at Morse Reservoir in Cicero, offers 16 hand-dipped ice cream flavors and 24 varieties of soft serve. Both locations provide a delightful experience for ice cream lovers and food enthusiasts alike, with gourmet chocolate candies available at the Noblesville site.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.039 reviews
Peter P.
9/24/2024
This is just a little ice cream stand next to the Boathouse. That's no inside seating, but there are numerous picnic tables in the grass. My milkshake was good and it came out fast (less than 3...
Jared M.
6/22/2024
Perfect stop on such a hot day! Server happily let us try a flavor before buying. I got the strawberry which was delicious. Got it in a waffle cone, which was ok, unfortunately stale in some parts...
Robert H.
10/7/2024
Travel through area often, Very busy Ice Cream shop. Always have had good service and excellent Ice Cream. Would recommend to anyone passing through area. One block off bridge. Picnic tables...
Jeff S.
6/29/2025
This could be a great place. The ice cream we ordered was not what we got. When I questioned our ice cream order, he told me that is what we ordered and proceeded to call the next order. WOW, no...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.