Sislers Ice Cream

Permanently closed
yelp logo

(7)

Photos

421 S Main St
Princeton, IL 61356
We are the 4th generation of Sisler's carrying on the ice cream business that was started by our great grandfather in 1908.

Reviews

yelp logo
4.57 reviews
Photo of Lynn H.
Lynn H.
9/20/2025

What a fun place! The young ladies that waited on my family were very welcoming and helpful. The ice cream was delicious ( I had the blueberry pie ice cream and it had pieces of crust in it-so...

Photo of Jessica M.
Jessica M.
7/22/2025

This was along the way on our return trip from Des Moines, Iowa to Chicago, Illinois. We tried the caramel praline, chocolate and moose tracks flavors. Everything was pretty standard. It was a...

Photo of Olivia O.
Olivia O.
6/7/2025

Great ice cream and popcorn. Anagrace was so kind and let us try so many flavors. Definitely a must try place. they have an amazing selection of ice cream flavors as well!

Edwin R.
7/3/2025

It started with the service. Very cordial and polite. The flavor choices were mouth watering and made it very difficult to choose. I went with my favorite which was butter pecan. As I savored the...

Dick M.
2/14/2024

We went into Sislers the other night, wanting a little dessert and got the most fantastic help and the ice cream was so good. They put extra stuff on it for me. I paid just a little bit more to...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesIllinoisPrincetonSislers Ice Cream

Partial Data by Foursquare.