Zack R.
7/20/2015
I hadn't been to Pagliai's in at least 13 years. The place hadn't changed a bit! The decor is still the same, the service is still top notch, and the pizza is still some of the best in...
Pagliai's Pizza
$
Closed
(69)
Photos
1600 Lincoln Ave
Charleston, IL 61920
Pagliai's Pizza has provided family dining to the East Central Illinois area since 1964. Our menu includes family recipes for pizza, spaghetti, tortellini, and more!
Reviews
4.069 reviews
Howard G.
7/14/2025
Get the house pizza if you wanna have the worst burbs ever. It's like you are reliving eating that garlic sausage with every burb...
Amber C.
5/21/2024
Great pizza. Thin crust which I love. Got the Pagliai's Special and the Vegetarian. My favorite was the Vegetarian. Came right before they were about to close. Service was great.
Sadie M.
7/14/2025
Super busy when we got there. Waited probably 15 min for our booth to be cleaned. Must have been a new waitress. Asked us 3 times for our drink orders. Couple we were with never did get silver...
Holly B.
6/10/2024
Never understood the hype over this place. We ordered a pan crust pepperoni and sausage pizza. It was terrible and had hardly any cheese on it. The family ate it because we were hungry.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.