Daniel S.
4/20/2025
Great food. Good lighting / decor. Everyone is friendly and good service. Very busy so shows it is popular.
Pagliai's Pizza
$
Closed
(68)
Photos
509 S Illinois Ave
Carbondale, IL 62901
Pagliai's Pizza, a beloved establishment in Carbondale, IL, has been serving up mouthwatering pizzas since 1968. With a rich history of crafting the finest pizza in Southern Illinois, Pagliai's has become a local favorite for residents and visitors alike.
Located at 509 S Illinois Ave, Carbondale, Pagliai's Pizza offers a diverse menu of delicious options beyond just their renowned pizzas. From comforting pasta dishes to flavorful salads, there is something to satisfy every craving at this longstanding pizzeria.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Reviews
3.068 reviewsJennifer L.
9/20/2025
Sad, I wanted to like Pagliai's, but I would not return. I might consider takeout pizza as the pizza was good, but would not eat there. It was an early dinner, we were one of three tables....
M. P.
10/25/2025
TLDR... ORDER FOR DELIVERY OR TAKE OUT ONLY!! SIU Alum, back for homecoming. Entered for dinner at 5:30. Only 2 servers on a Saturday night. "seat yourself" it says... Place is half full but in...
E.L. C.
5/3/2025
Sat down and waited 20 minutes to get a menu. Ordered 10 minutes later got our appetizer and drinks. 30 minutes they came to give us refills. 20 minutes later still did not have our drinks back...
Marilyn W.
1/21/2025
Another trip to southern Illinois from Texas and yet another great pizza at Pags. Thin crispy crust, plenty of toppings, tasty sausage and good red sauce. The former owners were there eating pizza...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.