Sherard C.
11/8/2025
Probably at one point in time, this was Chicago's best kept secret when it comes to pizza, I don't think this is any longer the case. Milly's is thriving as a no frills, "hole in the wall" pizza...
Milly’s Pizza In The Pan
$$
Closed
(190)
Photos
925 N Ashland Ave
Chicago, IL 60622
Milly’s Pizza In The Pan, located in Chicago, IL, is renowned for its commitment to quality, making a limited number of pizzas each day to ensure freshness and availability. The restaurant proudly sources all of its ingredients from local farmers and purveyors, emphasizing a farm-to-table approach.
Named after Grandma Emily and her husband Grandpa Joe, Milly’s Pizza In The Pan offers a unique dining experience that reflects a rich family heritage. Customers are encouraged to place orders online to secure their pizzas, highlighting the establishment's dedication to customer satisfaction.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5190 reviews
Samuel A.
11/8/2025
Milly's is a unique take on pizza for Chicago. I don't know many other pan style pizza spots around but the first comparison I could draw was to pequod's. Which Milly's blew pequod's out of the...
Allegra A.
11/2/2025
Alright we finally tried super hyped up Milly's and it did live up to the hype! This is the pan pizza Pequods wishes they could be (controversial opinion sorry not sorry). The caramelized crust is...
Len L.
10/3/2025
Took me a bit to figure out how I can order at Milly's. I tried for 2 weeks and finally able to order 2 pies on Thursday AM and pickup at 5 PM. I was able to order the craigslist and Leander. I...
David X.
10/20/2025
Out of the many deep dish pizzas I've had in Chicago, this one's currently my favorite. But be warned that they sell out early, so order days in advance or hope more become available the night...
See a problem?
