Elisabeth C.
8/28/2025
Ham sandwich is interesting, delicious, and traveled very well! Easy to put the leftovers in the fridge and reheat later. The peanut butter pie is so so rich and delicious!
First Slice Pie Cafe
Open
(25)
Photos
1969 W Montrose Ave
Chicago, IL 60613
First Slice Pie Cafe, located in Chicago, offers a unique Subscriber Program that allows patrons to enjoy three home-cooked meals each week while supporting local outreach efforts. The rotating menu features six entrees paired with sides and dessert, emphasizing the cafe's commitment to both quality dining and community assistance.
Renowned for its award-winning pies, such as the celebrated Key Lime and French Silk, First Slice also provides a variety of soups, salads, quiches, and sandwiches for those looking for a full meal. Since its founding, the cafe has been dedicated to helping those in need, serving approximately 4,000 meals each month to individuals experiencing hunger and homelessness.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.525 reviews
Sondra Z.
9/25/2025
Really wonderful neighborhood spot! Sweet and savory pies - regular pies, personal pies, quiche, and even pizza night! Great customer service as well!
Annette D.
7/30/2025
Hottest day of the year but no air conditioning was my first clue this would be a disappointing experience. I had ordered a whole pie ahead of time and arranged to pick it up on my way to a...
Emily T.
6/8/2025
No frills, quick service, perfect place to split a piece of a pie on a weekend morning. Feels homey and exactly what you want in a pie shop.
Monica V.
6/30/2024
Came here with friends on the recommendation of one of them. I wasn't even hungry, but the menu looked SO good that I ended up getting a sandwich--perfectly warm, melty, toasty and savory--as well...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.