William W P.
8/12/2025
Great family pizza treat. Wonderful ambiance, lots of games for kids, terrific menu choices with fantastic results when it comes to your table. God Bless!
Wiseguy Pizza Pie
$
Open
(69)
Photos
411 N Main St
Hailey, ID 83333
Wiseguy Pizza Pie is a local favorite in Hailey, ID, known for their commitment to quality and use of local fresh ingredients. Their New York style pizzas are hand-tossed, topped with whole-milk mozzarella sourced from Jerome, Idaho, and baked to perfection in stone deck ovens.
With a menu featuring delicious sandwiches, salads, and calzones, Wiseguy also offers a large selection of local bottled and draft beer, as well as wine options. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or ordering delivery, Wiseguy Pizza Pie is a must-visit for pizza lovers in the Wood River Valley.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.569 reviewsReshell S.
11/9/2025
Good pizza! Small space but the service is good. They sell whole pies or by the slice.
Lisa N.
7/6/2025
Great wings pizza and salads. We love stopping by here after a fun day in beautiful sawtooth mountains!
Some G.
6/12/2024
It's ok! With a name like Wiseguys, I was thinking it be a straight up New York slice. It kind of is, but only if you ordered it from Temu or Wish.com. It was more like sad New York slice and not...
Marvin Y.
3/1/2024
Pizza is definitely what they're known for. I really wish I could've tried the wings but never had the time to come back. I've had their pizza by the slice and it's very big and the crust is held...
See a problem?
