Arthur B.
12/17/2022
Not gonna lie, when it comes to my pizza, I'm a hard man to impress. Considered trying this place for years, but we're not in Idaho Falls very often. A friend recently recommended it, so we...
Lucys New York Style Pizzeria
Permanently closed
(113)
Photos
2770 S 25th E
Idaho Falls, ID 83404
Lucys New York Style Pizzeria, located in the heart of Idaho Falls, ID, is a haven for pizza enthusiasts seeking an authentic slice of the Big Apple. The cozy ambiance and mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked pies welcome guests to indulge in a culinary experience like no other. From classic pepperoni to gourmet veggie combinations, their menu boasts a diverse selection to satisfy every craving.
Patrons can watch skilled chefs toss dough in the air before it's transformed into piping hot pies bubbling with cheese and savory toppings. Whether you're dining in or grabbing a quick takeaway, Lucys New York Style Pizzeria promises a slice of New York's iconic pizza culture right here in Idaho Falls. Come taste the passion and dedication that goes into each flavorful creation at this charming pizzeria.
Generated using this place's available information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0113 reviews
Hayley E.
6/21/2025
We like the crunch of the wings but the buffalo sauce tasted store bought. Nothing special to the flavor. We rank pizza as number 3 to mackenzie river then papa tom's then this. We enjoyed the...
Joe W.
7/1/2025
The service was great, pizza was substandard. Almost no toppings on a three meat pizza, the center of the pizza was like wet bread and the rest was burnt. If I was going to compare it to my...
April J.
8/26/2024
The pizza at this Lucy's is almost always perfection. Sometimes the cooks burn the pizza but it's very rare. Cheese sticks, fried muzz and cannoli's are always a hit with me as well. My big issue...
Joshua B.
10/14/2022
9/10 The pizza here is amazing, hands down way better then all of your main stream pizza joints. Our favorite thing to order are the Honey Garlic Wings, they are so delicious and what you want in...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.