The Maui Cookie Lady

$
Closed
yelp logo

(345)

Call
Website

Photos

3643 Baldwin Ave
Makawao, HI 96768
+1 (808) 793-3172
http://www.themauicookielady.com
Only 1 Location in Historic Makawao Town. A fairytale whimsical cookie cafe meets Willy Wonka in charming Historical Makawao Town. Our only location in Maui's slopes of Haleakala is filled with desserts to satisfy any sweet tooth. Each batch of artisan cookies are handmade in the commercial kitchen located behind the retail shop in Makawao Town. The sweet shop also carries scrumptious ice cream bars, artisan confectionaries, gourmet popcorn, locally brewed cold coffees and lemonade. Customers of all ages find treats to enjoy. The Maui Cookie Lady has been featured in "O" Magazine, Rachel Ray in Season, Food Network Magazine, GMA, FORBES, Hawai'i Magazine, Entrepreneur, Men's Magazine and was named Taste of Home Magazine Top 10 Cookies in 2020 to ship online. This bakery is a Maui attraction not to be missed!

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.5345 reviews
Photo of Jeseila E.
Jeseila E.
10/26/2025

A sweet Maui Must- stop! The Maui Cookie Lady shop is such a gem! The moment you walk in, it smells amazing -- warm, cozy, and a little earthy. The shop itself is small, but it has such a...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Jen M.
Jen M.
9/28/2025

Had to stop by the cutest store to pick up some treats for a friends kids. They open at 10 am now but it fit our schedule perfectly today. Saw that they now offer a variety bag of 4 cookies! So...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Sue S.
Sue S.
8/6/2025

IMHO If you visit Makawao, you MUST visit the Maui Cookie Lady store! It's the cutest, most whimsical store in town! It's chock full of wonder and fantasy, and HUMONGOUS and delectable cookies,...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Cathrine S.
Cathrine S.
7/21/2025

The cutest little cookie shop! Fairy themed, this shop is so unique and whimsical. We tried the Kona Coffee espresso & butter rum, both were so delicious, fresh, moist, and well portioned - big...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Dave C.
Dave C.
8/22/2025

Quaint kitschy hobbit-like ambience, friendly service, interesting back story and awards galore- sadly we didn't like the cookies here very much. We tried the white chocolate macadamia nut and...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Pono Pies
Eating places, Pizza restaurants

Pono Pies

35
•
$
"It's not often you find the perfect dessert...but a Pono Pie is certainly a contender. Made of all local Hawaiian ingredients and without added sugar (just a touch of honey), these not-too-sweet,..."
photo of Ann C.
Papi's Ohana
Eating places, Pizza restaurants

Papi's Ohana

712
•
$
"The nicest people !!!! The coffee is great We did the cookies and took them back home to Texas . Cinnamon rolls are incredible and I will forever be trying to find one that beats that cinnamon roll"
photo of Denee H.
Maui Manjookies
Eating places

Maui Manjookies

57
•
$
"Mauijookies... Gotta love to find this local fave at the Food and New Product show a fun event that's been around for quite some time though the same remains the same concept has shifted a bit..."
photo of Irene M.
United States›Hawaii›The Maui Cookie Lady

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.