Holly M.
8/10/2025
The ease of ordering online and pickup took a lot of headaches away. The cookie cake was perfect- delicious and beautiful.
Great American Cookies
Closed
(5)
Photos
5405 Jefferson Rd
Athens, GA 30607
What started with a generations-old family Cookie Cake recipe in 1977 with only the best premium ingredients, Great American Cookies is the sweet spot for happiness and joy. We are still the home of the original Cookie Cake, just re-imagined with life's sweet moments as our inspiration. Passionate bakers are devoted to hand-crafting fresh-baked Cookies, Double Doozies, and of course our custom-designed original Cookie Cakes. With bakeries across the country, in your neighborhood, and treats available for delivery right to your door, the sweet spot is always close to home.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.05 reviews
Amanda W.
7/7/2025
Fool me once... I'm back for the second time in less than a year with a poor review. I placed my cookie cake order a week in advance. The young man who took my order said they opened at 10:00 on...
Stephanie C.
3/5/2025
Really nice, clean shop with excellent customer service! I was lucky they had a large cookie cake available, and the staff member customized it perfectly for a birthday. Super helpful and made the...
Pales S.
1/5/2025
Almost broke my tooth biting into these cookies, they are so STALE. The cookies slices were also recycled, you can clearly tell they were made the day before and put new icing over it. I'm sad...
Maggie S.
10/21/2024
Hi Great American Cookies! I have always loved your cookies my entire life, and I was so excited to see you opened up a location in Athens. I went yesterday for this first time to get my boyfriend...
Owner verified
See a problem?
