What the Fish Rolls & More

$$
Open
yelp logo

(680)

Photos

90775 Old Hwy Unit 6
Tavernier, FL 33070
What The Fish Rolls & More focuses mainly on ocean to table/locally caught specialties such as seasonal favorites like crab cakes or lobster rolls and a wide variety of seafood-related buns and ready-to-eat entrées.

Reviews

yelp logo
5.0680 reviews
Photo of Danielle T.
Danielle T.
8/17/2025

On our way up from Marathon, we were in the car discussing how unimpressed we were with food down in the Florida Keys, particularly the fish. We were looking for 2 things: freshness &...

Photo of Alex S.
Alex S.
11/23/2025

Really great shrimp rolls and fish tacos in an off the beaten path spot in the middle Keys. Love eating on the water and also seeing nurse sharks just off the dock. Very friendly manager/owner who...

Photo of Yunnuen P.
Yunnuen P.
4/21/2025

You don't want to leave the keys without checking this place out. If you're a first timer; Alex walks you through the menu like a breeze. Tells you what's what and what's the catch of the day....

Photo of Althea L.
Althea L.
4/17/2025

This was by far the best meal we had in the Florida Keys. Most of the other restaurants we tried were unfortunately underwhelming--the food just didn't live up to the hype on social media or...

Photo of M T.
M T.
10/12/2025

We stopped in for some rolls after finding this place on yelp. We got a lobster roll that didn't have FL lobster. Instead, it had Maine lobster even though it was a few days into lobster season in...

Owner verified
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesFloridaTavernierWhat the Fish Rolls & More

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.