What The Fish Rolls

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(677)

Call
Website

Photos

90775 Old Hwy Unit 6
Tavernier, FL 33070
+1 (305) 440-3650
http://whatthefishrolls.com
What The Fish Rolls & More focuses mainly on ocean to table/locally caught specialties such as seasonal favorites like crab cakes or lobster rolls and a wide variety of seafood-related buns and ready-to-eat entrées.

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
5.0677 reviews
Photo of Danielle T.
Danielle T.
8/17/2025

On our way up from Marathon, we were in the car discussing how unimpressed we were with food down in the Florida Keys, particularly the fish. We were looking for 2 things: freshness &...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Yunnuen P.
Yunnuen P.
4/21/2025

You don't want to leave the keys without checking this place out. If you're a first timer; Alex walks you through the menu like a breeze. Tells you what's what and what's the catch of the day....

Read more on Yelp
Photo of M T.
M T.
10/12/2025

We stopped in for some rolls after finding this place on yelp. We got a lobster roll that didn't have FL lobster. Instead, it had Maine lobster even though it was a few days into lobster season in...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Susan A.
Susan A.
9/29/2025

Holy cow! Best lobster roll ever, and I used to live in New England! Calamari was crisp and perfectly cooked. The casa mar fresh local fish was perfectly seasoned. The green dressing on the...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of David D.
David D.
10/13/2025

Really good fresh fish. Came in and the guy who seemed like the owner was super nice and helpful. Would eat there again for sure

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

The Mar Bar
Bars and lounges, Eating places, Bar (drinking places)

The Mar Bar

82
•
$$
"Stone crabs and High Noons after a day of fishing with Captain Perkins. We pulled up to the dock from the boat, we're seated and dining within moments. Def stopping on my next ride through."
photo of Win G.
Steak and barbecue restaurants

Islamorada Lobster Corp

Islamorada Lobster Corp is a seafood company based in Tavernier, FL, specializing in the distribution and sale of fresh lobster products. With a focus on quality and sustainability, the company sources its lobsters from reputable suppliers and delivers them to customers seeking premium seafood options. Generated from their business information
Eating places

Islamorada Lobster Co

Islamorada Lobster Co is a seafood restaurant in Tavernier, FL, known for its fresh and delicious lobster dishes. The establishment offers a casual dining experience with a focus on serving high-quality seafood to its customers. With a menu featuring a variety of lobster-based dishes, Islamorada Lobster Co caters to seafood lovers looking for a taste of the local cuisine. The restaurant prides itself on providing a welcoming atmosphere for guests to enjoy a satisfying meal in a relaxed setting. Generated from their business information
United States›Florida›Tavernier›What The Fish Rolls

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.