Avree R.
8/17/2025
We love Tony's when we need a quick & fast, pick me up. We always ordered the slices to go. They hear them up and then you're good to go. Big slices too! Think Costco size but a little smaller....
Tony's NY Pizza
Open
(71)
Photos
145 S Barfield Dr
Marco Island, FL 34145
Tony's NY Pizza is an authentic New York pizzeria located in Marco Island, Florida, celebrated for bringing a slice of New York to the Sunshine State. Known as the most talked-about pizzeria in the area, it offers a delightful menu that caters to pizza lovers of all ages.
With a commitment to quality and flavor, Tony's NY Pizza has become a go-to destination for those craving classic New York-style pizza. Its convenient location on S. Barfield Drive makes it an ideal spot for locals and visitors alike.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.071 reviewsAndrew W.
9/9/2025
I ordered a medium pizza and a cannoli. The pizza was top-tier, but the cannoli had zero filling in the middle. If you're going for the pizza, that's great. However, if you order the cannoli,...
Raymond P.
8/27/2025
If you like garlic knots that are burnt on the top and bottom, this place is for you. My order was to go. I'm sure they would not have served them to anyone eating in. Ray P
Nelson I.
10/31/2024
Take out order. First time customers as we were on vacation. Food was excellent . Only issue was no bags of chips. Had to go close by to get chips
Cath S.
4/17/2025
Every time we visit Marco Island, we always come to Tony's NY pizza. Delicious pizza we always ordered pepperoni with anchovies never disappoint us. Great service very friendly people and staffs....
See a problem?
