Tracy D.
10/5/2025
Last week or so, I wrote a review about Tony's pizza and how horrible the pizza was because they consistently burn the pies. However, I neglected to mention the location, which was Daniel's...
Tonys NY Pizza
$
Closed
(196)
Photos
3398 Forum Blvd Ste 101
Ft Myers, FL 33905
New York Style Pizzeria
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5196 reviews
Jill W.
11/3/2025
Super busy at lunch time, they have several different slices. This is by far my most favorite pizza in fort Myers! The resturant is on the small side but they also have outdoor seating. The garlic...
Colleen R.
11/17/2024
The food was delicious Every time I'm in town I make it a point to go there friendly service clean highly recommend
Susan W.
8/23/2025
We love this pizza! Backyard was New Haven and NYC and Tony's comes Deliciously close! You won't be disappointed!
Luis F.
7/23/2025
The pizza here is phenomenal. Is it is as authentic as it comes. Best New York pizza in all of Florida.
See a problem?
