Seanmayra R.
11/2/2025
Always the best spot!!! We as locals love love this place!!!!! Pizza, food, all of it amazing
The Whistle Stop and Stone Oven Pizzeria
$$
Closed
(83)
Photos
82685 Overseas Hwy
Islamorada, FL 33036
The Whistle Stop and Stone Oven Pizzeria located in the beautiful Islamorada FL offers a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for families and friends. Enjoy a delicious selection of handcrafted pizzas baked in a traditional stone oven alongside a variety of mouthwatering dishes that highlight fresh local ingredients. Whether you're dining in or grabbing a slice to go this eatery promises a delightful experience for pizza lovers and food enthusiasts alike.
Generated from this place's information
Also at this address
Reviews
3.583 reviews
Rachel R.
11/6/2025
We stopped in here late night after it being recommended by the bartender at Florida Keys Brewery. Upon pulling up, you might think that it would be a little rough inside, but quite the opposite!...
Jvjv P.
8/20/2025
i hate to say it but the food was great ngl. wings pizza salad all was great. the service however... absolutely terrible. if u order anything other than a beer, the insanely sassy goofy ssa...
Kim L.
6/6/2025
We had a few pizzas delivered the other night, both were build your own. Pizzas arrived fast and hot and we were pleasantly surprised at how yummy they were. One was a pesto pizza with chicken and...
Michael U.
9/11/2025
Late night at the Whistle Stop while on the island has always been great for me. Its gonna get late and not many places to choose, however, this place is perfect for those that want to grab a few...
See a problem?
