The Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry

$
Closed
tripadvisor logo

(55)

Call
Website

Photos

1455 SR-436 Ste 105
Casselberry, FL 32707
+1 (407) 657-5384
http://originalanthonys.com
Yes, this is the original Anthony’s NY Pizza of Orlando. This location was the first to open back in 1987 and we’ve served the Casselberry, Maitland, Winter Park area for 37 years! Come try our delicious food with oversized portions today!

Also at this address

Reviews

tripadvisor logo
4.055 reviews
Photo of Peter W
TOTAL FAILURE
7/31/2024

Been going ther since it opened in 1987. I'm a local. Ordered the meatlovers calzone like I have 50 ...

Read more on Tripadvisor
Photo of AmorAngel
Don’t waste your money!
5/31/2024

I visited today. The food was bland, no flavor. The lettuce in the salad was brown and they don’t gi...

Read more on Tripadvisor
Photo of Sightseer06495640155
Terrible Place Avoid at all costs
7/23/2023

Take out, pizza was terrible. Alfredo sauce on the pasta we ordered tasted like canned sauce you ge...

Read more on Tripadvisor
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Digino's Pizza Bar & Grill
Eating places, Italian restaurant

Digino's Pizza Bar & Grill

92
•
$
"Everything I've had here has been REALLY good, with good prices and big portions. You can't go wrong with the pizza, calzones, garlic knots, salads, the chicken Cesar wrap, wings and subs. Really..."
photo of Toby T.
Boardwalk Pizza
Eating places, Italian restaurant, Delicatessen (eating places)

Boardwalk Pizza

139
•
$
"Nice it's a little more than a pizza parlor. Great food great service I will definitely be going there again."
photo of Randy L.
Tuscany Pizza
Eating places, Italian restaurant, Bar (drinking places)

Tuscany Pizza

146
•
$
"Our first time here and we ordered a Tuscan combination and it was really good! The service was amazing. Would definitely recommend and come back again!!!"
United States›Florida›Casselberry›The Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry