Straight From New York Bagels

$
Closed
yelp logo

(178)

Photos

4550 Executive Dr Ste 1
Naples, FL 34119
Straight From New York Bagel is famous for our traditional, fresh baked, kettle-boiled bagels that were voted Best Bagel in South West Florida by Gulfshore Life. Our amazing bagels along with our house-whipped spreads, pastries, bialys, cinnamon rolls, breakfast sandwiches and rich and flavorful locally sourced coffee make us your go to stop for breakfast seven days a week. But it doesn’t stop with breakfast! Stop by for lunch and wrap two hands around our giant New York-style deli sandwiches along with one of our delicious house made salads or sides. Don’t have time to stop in? Straight From New York Bagels offers deliver for all catering orders. Business Meetings, Church and School Functions, Birthdays, Holidays or any reason for a gathering, Straight From New York Bagels makes catering your events easy, convenient and affordable. During the season find us around town too. Every weekend we’re serving our fresh bagels and coffee at one of your favorite Farmer’s Markets. Straight From New York Bagel, one taste and you’ll know why they say it’s SIMPLY THE BEST!

Reviews

yelp logo
3.5178 reviews
Photo of Cody K.
Cody K.
7/5/2025

One of the best bagels we've had in a while. Got a bacon, egg and cheese on plain, as well as a sausage, egg and cheese on jalapeño cheddar. Bacon could've been a little more crispy, but it was...

Photo of Dave L.
Dave L.
5/6/2025

This is a gem. A little hidden from the main road. Fantastic bagels. They really got it right in fact, all the food is fantastic, as well as the coffee. Really friendly service, five stars all day!

Photo of Madonna D.
Madonna D.
12/28/2023

Friendly service. Large selection of bagels and salads--they also have bialys and NY-area treats like crumb cake and Italian cookies. Bagels have the chewy texture and blistered skin that I...

Todd k.
7/21/2025

Sooooo over priced, 16$ for a bagel with lox when I asked for a bagel with lox spread. I paid left and was happy, but not what ordered, eh bagels are decent just way over priced. I live down the...

Hayley P.
5/25/2025

We have been going here for years, and over the years the food has slowly gone down hill. Today will be the last time I eat from Straight from NY, I say eat but I threw my roll in the trash. Not...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesFloridaNaplesStraight From New York Bagels

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.