martyz50
7/6/2025
5 Stars We ordered a Sicilian pizza and a supreme calzone from Serafina's Pizza, and it was a bit of a mixed experience at first. The calzone was incredible -- huge, loaded with toppings, and...
Serafina's Pizzeria
$
Closed
(329)
Photos
4125 Race Track Rd
Saint Johns, FL 32259
Welcome to Serafina's Pizzeria, bringing a slice of Brooklyn to St. Johns, FL! Conveniently located near Fruit Cove, Mandarin, and Ponte Vedra Beach, we specialize in authentic Brooklyn-style pizza made with the finest ingredients. Each 18” hand-tossed pie boasts a crispy edge and soft, foldable center, just like it should be. Our menu features Italian-American favorites such as calzones, pasta, heroes, and savory appetizers like garlic knots and mozzarella sticks. Whether you’re craving a classic slice or a specialty pie, we’ve got you covered. Serving Bayard, Nocatee, St. Augustine, Fleming Island, and beyond—come for the pizza, stay for the family-friendly vibe!
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5329 reviews
Elise B.
11/18/2025
Really good authentic pizza. Super crispy crust on the bottom and edge I got the lunch deal. Two really big pizza slices and a drink for $8.40. Great deal super nice lady at the front and chill...
Monica C.
5/18/2025
Today I tried the Sicilian pizza square, with pepperoni, yummyyyyyyy. Girls at counter are so kind and professional as always.
Joyce S.
3/6/2025
My husband and I picked up a supreme pizza, which has pepperoni, jalapeño (added on), mushroom, bell peppers, and onions. It was delicious! Served very hot so still warm by the time we got home....
Craig E.
6/28/2025
We're born and raised Long Islanders, and both worked in Manhattan for years before escaping from the People's Republic of New York and landing in Jacksonville. We've eaten in the best pizzerias...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.