Seby’s Pizza

Closed
yelp logo

(47)

Photos

1555 State Road 436 Ste 1321
Winter Park, FL 32792

Seby’s Pizza, nestled in Winter Park, FL, brings a taste of New York to the Orlando area courtesy of pizzaiolo Sebastian "Seby" Donofrio, a third-generation Italian-American with a deep-rooted passion for pizza. Drawing inspiration from renowned pizzerias in Brooklyn and Manhattan, Chef Seby's expertise shines through in every slice.

What sets Seby’s apart is their attention to detail, starting with their dough-making process. By utilizing a high-quality reverse osmosis water system sourced from New York, they ensure their dough reaches its full flavor potential. Their multi-phase fermentation process and the use of a spiral mixer further elevate the taste and consistency of their crust.

At Seby's, quality is paramount. From using freshly shredded whole-milk mozzarella to handcrafting meatballs in-house, every ingredient is carefully selected and prepared to guarantee a top-notch pizza experience. It’s the meticulous focus on the finer points that sets Seby’s apart and beckons pizza enthusiasts to savor the difference for themselves.

Generated from the website content

Reviews

yelp logo
5.047 reviews
Photo of Sebastian B.
Sebastian B.
9/10/2025

Pizza is a staple yet with so many choices how do you find that must have, go to, Pizzeria? You look for passion, detail, and creativity. Seby's Pizza is all that and more. The owner and his staff...

Photo of Cheryl Emily B.
Cheryl Emily B.
8/3/2025

I needed a quick spot to order dinner and decided to try Seby's Pizza since its not to far. Off the bat, I have to say on experience and service alone, the owner was super kind and friendly. He...

Photo of Mark S.
Mark S.
5/11/2025

Great find: I got a mailer delivered from here, and it had no coupon, and I was kind of shocked (no coupon?!), but also intrigued. I looked it up on google and Yelp and the reviews were...

Photo of Lydia C.
Lydia C.
9/9/2025

I recently tried Seby's Pizza through doordash delivery and it was phenomenal! I ordered the 18" cheese pizza and the 12" Nolita (tomato sauce, shredded mozzarella and provolone blend, pepperoni,...

Photo of Stephanie G.
Stephanie G.
3/14/2025

My social media algorithm knows me wayyy too well, because it brought me to Seby's! As soon as I read that the place is run by New York Italians from Long Island, I grabbed my mom and ran off to...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesFloridaWinter ParkSeby’s Pizza